Pooh from Winnie-the-Pooh: Blood and Honey

After Winnie-the-Pooh entered the public domain on January 1, 2022, Rhys Frake-Waterfield set out to write, produce, and direct a gory horror film based on the property. In Winnie-the-Pooh: Blood and Honey, an adult Christopher Robin returns to Hundred Acre Wood after a 5 year absence. He finds the land desolate and the creatures starving and feral. Pooh and Piglet ambush Christopher and his wife, dragging them into the woods.

Mickey from Mickey’s Mouse Trap

With Disney’s copyright on the classic cartoon Steamboat Willie expiring, creators wasted no time taking advantage. On the very day the Mickey Mouse short entered the public domain – January 1, 2024 – a trailer for a horror slasher called Mickey’s Mouse Trap dropped, continuing the tradition of the previous year’s Winnie-the-Pooh: Blood and Honey. In the film, a killer masked as Mickey Mouse (Simon Phillips) stalks victims at a late-night birthday party in an amusement park. To take your costume from mascot to monster, cut out or black out the eye holes of your rubber Mickey mask.

boris the teeth guy from goanimate

Boris the Teeth Guy from Goanimate

Boris the Teeth Guy is one of the antagonists of Goanimate.  Boris is an extremely loud and angry character who yells constantly.  Boris a “teeth person,” and is red with a large mouth.  His clothes consist of red shoes, blue pants, and a green hoodie.  You can make the drawstrings of the hoodie red with fabric paint.  You’ll also need red face paint for your face and red gloves.

Jeffy from SML

Jeffy from SML

In the YouTube series SML (formerly SuperMarioLogan), Jeffy Jeffy is the adoptive son of Rose and Marvin, who he spends his days annoying. He wears a blue helmet and has a shirt with his name written on it by his mom… so he won’t forget his name. To fully commit to this costume you’ll want to keep a pencil (the rubber variety is recommended for safety) shoved up your nose, and diapers worn outside your pants. The better to keep your diaper clean.

nina the killer from creepypasta

Nina the Killer

Nina the Killer is the titular serial killer character at the heart of a CreepyPasta story.  Originally a fan of Jeff the Killer, Nina Hopkins turns down her own twisted path after a bad day at school.  Nina is a high school girl with long dark hair that she wears in a ponytail with a red bow and a single streak of purple.  Her outfit includes a hoodie, a black pleated skirt, and black and red striped thigh-high socks.  Perhaps the most striking aspect of Nina’s appearance is her Chelsea Smile, which you can achieve with a little liquid latex, fake blood, and some patience.

ethan mars from heavy rain

Ethan Mars from Heavy Rain

Ethan Mars (voiced by Pascal Langdale) is one of four playable characters in the action-adventure game Heavy Rain.  After another painful loss, Ethan’s son is kidnapped by the Origami Killer and he must do everything he can to save him. Ethan became a meme when the “Press X to Shaun” glitch was discovered. Ethan’s primary outfit throughout the game includes a brown jacket, blue jeans, and dark work boots.  If you’re not ready to grow out your own five-o’clock-shadow, using a brown eyebrow pencil can help you shade your face to look more haggard.

Orb Pondering Wizard

The orb pondering wizard is the subject of the “Pondering My Orb” meme. More simply known as “Ponder Orb,” this meme became viral on Twitter in October 2021. The original picture comes from a 1988 gamebook titled Middle-Earth Quest: A Spy In Isengard, for a role-playing game based on Lord of the Rings. Perhaps this wizard is related to Gandalf?

Cal Chuchesta

Cal Chuchesta

Cal Chuchesta is the weird, bumbling, but extremely talented roommate of famous YouTube music critic Anthony Fantano. Cal is fierce behind the keyboards and unrivaled with his songwriting. Cal also has a keen sense of fashion, with his XXXL sweater, manly mustache, and steely squint.

Anthony Fantano

Anthony Fantano

Anthony Fantano is the Internet’s busiest music nerd. His time is filled playing bass and reviewing albums on his popular YouTube channel, The Needle Drop. Fantano is known for his uncanny resemblance to a melon, his vast collection of plaid flannel shirts — each color having a deep symbolic meaning, and for having the best teeth in the game. Fantano’s roommates with the eccentric Cal Chuchesta, who he hates.

milkman karlson

Milkman Karlson

In the eponymous video game created by YouTuber Dani, Milkman Karlson must make his way to the store to buy milk.  However, this is no ordinary milk run, with enemies appearing in his path to slow him down.  Milkman Karlson must use his weapons to dispatch of these enemies and he can earn money by not only killing his enemies, but by doing “epic” tricks and flips.  To dress as Milkman Karlson, you’ll need a black shirt, yellow pants, and blue overshirt.  For a little extra pizzazz, you can also opt for a pair of googly eye glasses and bright green socks to pull it all together.

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.